A Coordinated Electric System Interconnection Review—the utility’s deep-dive on technical and cost impacts of your project.

Challenge: Frequent false tripping using conventional electromechanical relays
Solution: SEL-487E integration with multi-terminal differential protection and dynamic inrush restraint
Result: 90% reduction in false trips, saving over $250,000 in downtime

The three operating regions you have to design to

Device Output vs voltage Response Best suited to Main limitations
Mechanically switched capacitor or reactor Proportional to voltage squared Seconds; discrete steps; limited switching operations per day Steady-state reactive supply, voltage profile, loss reduction No dynamic capability; step voltage change on switching; capability collapses when most needed
Static var compensator Capacitive branches proportional to voltage squared A few cycles; continuously controllable Continuous control where cost matters and deep voltage support is not the driver Square-law capability loss; harmonic filters are part of the plant and interact with the network
STATCOM Approximately proportional to voltage — constant current capability One to two cycles closed loop; converter response faster still Voltage stability margin, weak interconnections, fast disturbance recovery, flicker and unbalance compensation Higher capital cost; converter losses; adds a converter and its control dynamics to the network
Synchronous condenser Governed by machine capability and excitation Excitation response in the hundreds of milliseconds; inherent inertial response instantaneous System strength and inertia, short-circuit contribution, black start support Rotating plant with maintenance and losses; slower controlled response than a converter
STATCOM with energy storage Reactive as a STATCOM, plus real power within the storage rating As STATCOM for reactive; real power limited by storage Where a real power deficiency is part of the problem Cost and complexity of the storage; different failure and maintenance profile
Stage Keentel scope Outcome
Screening Series-compensation proximity, radial contingency review, UIF and short-circuit ratio screening, frequency scans Early identification of which SSO types apply
Detailed studies PSCAD/EMTDC EMT studies with vendor real-code models, impedance-based and frequency-scan analysis Clear evidence of stability margins or risk
Model quality EMT model review, benchmarking against positive-sequence models, model acceptance support Models that system operators accept
Mitigation Control retuning recommendations with vendors, SSDC and bypass logic requirements, protection and monitoring specifications Practical, coordinated solutions
Interconnection support SSR and SSO study reports for ISO and utility requirements, response to reviewer comments Fewer delays in the interconnection process

Resilience: designing CDUs to the facility Tier objective


Liquid cooling makes heat removal more critical, not less. Cold plates hold only seconds of thermal buffer. If TCS flow stops, processors throttle or shut down very quickly. Resilience design must therefore cover:


  • Pump redundancy: N+1 pumps at minimum, with automatic changeover.
  • CDU redundancy: N+1 CDUs on a common TCS header, or 2N CDUs serving A and B manifolds for fault-tolerant designs.
  • Power to CDUs: dual-corded CDUs fed from A and B sources, with pumps and controls on UPS power so coolant keeps flowing through a utility failure and generator start. This is the liquid-cooling equivalent of continuous cooling.
  • Facility water continuity: chilled water or condenser water must also continue, through thermal storage, UPS-backed pumps or a high enough FWS temperature that the TCS can coast on stored thermal mass for the transfer period.
  • Concurrent maintainability: isolation valves so any CDU, pump, filter or manifold section can be serviced without stopping the others.
  • Leak management: leak detection, drip trays, automatic isolation valves and procedures for fluid spills.


Electrical engineering considerations


CDUs and liquid-cooling plants are electrical loads with their own design requirements:


  • Pump motors and VFDs. Large CDUs use variable-frequency drives on their pump motors. These introduce harmonic current that must be included in the facility's harmonic study and IEEE 519 evaluation.
  • Critical mechanical load on UPS. Putting CDU pumps on UPS increases UPS and battery sizing. The mechanical UPS load must be included in redundancy and ride-through calculations.
  • Feeder and protection design. Dual feeds, automatic transfer, selective coordination and arc-flash labelling apply to CDU power distribution just as they do to IT power.
  • Generator transient response. CDU pumps restarting together after a transfer create motor inrush on the generators. Staged restarts and soft acceleration reduce the step load.
  • Load dynamics. AI training loads can swing rapidly between high and low power. Cooling controls must track those swings without temperature overshoot, and electrical systems must handle both the IT and the cooling load changes.


Commissioning a liquid-cooled data hall


  1. Flush and clean the TCS piping and manifolds to the specified cleanliness, using high-purity flush water.
  2. Fill and vent with the specified coolant, verifying glycol concentration and chemistry.
  3. Pressure test for leaks at design and test pressures, including quick-disconnect fittings.
  4. Verify sensors and controls: flow meters, temperature sensors, pressure transmitters, leak detection and BMS points.
  5. Load test with heat load banks connected through the cold-plate interfaces or rack manifolds, across the operating range.
  6. Prove the heat balance on both loops at several load steps, and the approach temperature against the design.
  7. Test failure scenarios: pump failure, CDU failure, power transfer to generator, valve failure and loss of facility water, confirming temperatures stay within the IT vendor's limits.


How Keentel Engineering helps


Keentel Engineering supports data center owners, developers and EPCs with the electrical engineering that liquid-cooled facilities depend on, and coordinates with the mechanical engineer of record and cooling vendors on the integrated design.


Power Swing Blocking, Out-of-Step Tripping and NERC PRC-026: How Distance Relays Tell Swings from Faults

Power swing blocking and NERC PRC-026 protection diagram showing distance relay zones and swing locus.
Calendar icon. D

November 14, 2026 | Blog

Part A — Power Swing Protection at a Glance

When a transmission system is disturbed, the rotors of the synchronous machines on either side of the disturbance do not move together. A fault, a line trip, a large generator trip or a switching event changes the power that each machine can deliver, and the machines accelerate or decelerate against one another. The angle between the internal voltages of two groups of machines rises, overshoots and oscillates. Active power flowing between the groups oscillates with it. That oscillation is a power swing.

To a distance relay, a power swing looks a great deal like a fault. The relay calculates apparent impedance from local voltage and current. As the angle between the two system voltages increases, the voltage at the relay falls, the current rises, and the apparent impedance moves from the load region on the right of the R–X plane toward, and sometimes through, the relay's protection zones. If the impedance enters a zone and stays long enough, the relay trips, even though there is no fault on the line.

An unwanted line trip during a stable swing is more than a nuisance. It removes transmission capacity at exactly the moment the system is working hardest to resynchronize, and it can turn a recoverable disturbance into a cascade. Several of the most significant North American disturbances, including the August 14, 2003 blackout, involved distance relays operating on power swings and apparent-impedance excursions that were not faults. Conversely, if the swing is unstable, the system must be separated, and it should be separated at locations and angles chosen by engineers, not wherever a distance relay happens to sit near the electrical center.

This guide explains how modern numerical relays distinguish power swings from faults, how power swing blocking (PSB) and out-of-step tripping (OST) are set, and how NERC Reliability Standard PRC-026 governs the response of load-responsive protective relays to stable power swings on the US bulk electric system (BES). It is written for protection engineers, planning engineers, compliance managers at Transmission Owners and Generator Owners, and owner's engineers who need settings that are both secure and defensible at audit.

Related Keentel reading. Our guide to ground distance protection covers zone reach, polarization and quadrilateral characteristics. The transient stability guide covers critical clearing time and rotor-angle stability. The TPL-001-5.1 guide covers the planning studies that feed PRC-026. This article builds on all three and focuses on power swing detection and PRC-026 compliance.

Who this guide is for

  • Protection engineers who set distance relays at 69 kV through 765 kV and must decide whether to enable power swing blocking, how wide to set the swing characteristics, and how to unblock for faults during a swing.
  • Planning engineers who run TPL-001 dynamic studies and must identify Elements for PRC-026 Requirement R1 and provide the data that relay owners need.
  • Compliance managers at Transmission Owners and Generator Owners who must produce evidence that every identified Element was evaluated, and that any relay failing the criteria has a Corrective Action Plan.
  • Generator and IBR plant owners whose generator step-up transformers, interconnection lines and generator relays fall within PRC-026 applicability.
  • Owner's engineers and developers who need to understand how a new plant or line changes swing behavior on neighboring relays.

What a power swing is, in one paragraph

Consider two equivalent sources, E_S at the sending end and E_R at the receiving end, connected through a total transfer impedance. The active power transferred is proportional to the sine of the angle between them. After a disturbance the angle oscillates. If the oscillation is damped and the angle settles at a new steady value, the swing is stable. If the angle keeps increasing past 180 degrees and the sources slip poles, the swing is unstable and the system has lost synchronism, which is called an out-of-step condition. Stable swings must not trip lines. Unstable swings must be separated in a controlled way.

The core ideas in one table

Topic What engineers need to know
Why swings affect distance relays Apparent impedance during a swing travels across the R–X plane. Near the electrical center, at large angles, it can be inside zone 1, zone 2 or zone 3.
Electrical center The point on the system impedance where voltage passes through zero when the angle reaches 180 degrees. If it lies on a protected line, that line's relays will see the swing deep inside their zones.
Power swing blocking (PSB) Detects a swing and blocks selected distance zones so they do not trip during a stable swing.
Out-of-step tripping (OST) Detects an unstable swing and trips selected breakers to separate the system at a planned location and angle.
Classic detection principle Measure the time the impedance takes to travel between two concentric characteristics. Slow travel means a swing; near-instant travel means a fault.
Modern detection principles Continuous impedance-rate supervision, swing-center voltage rate of change, and current or power pattern methods that need fewer system-specific settings.
Faults during a swing Need dedicated unblocking logic: negative-sequence or zero-sequence current supervision, sudden-change detectors and special logic for three-phase faults.
Load encroachment The outer swing characteristic must stay clear of maximum load (PRC-023 basis), which limits how wide it can be set.
NERC PRC-026 Requires Planning Coordinators to identify Elements susceptible to swings and requires Transmission Owners and Generator Owners to show that their load-responsive relays on those Elements are not expected to trip for stable swings.

Fact check: what the simple explanations get right and wrong

Short explanations of power swing protection often describe the logic as "if the impedance enters the inner zone but stays inside the outer zone, it is a swing; if it leaves the outer zone, a trip is permitted." That summary contains a real idea but misstates how detection works. The table below sets out Keentel's assessment of the common claims.

Common claim Keentel assessment
"If the measured point enters the inner zone but stays inside the outer zone, the relay identifies a power swing." Incomplete. Classic schemes declare a swing when the impedance takes longer than a set time (often 1 to 4 cycles, set from the fastest expected swing) to travel from the outer to the inner characteristic. Position alone cannot separate a swing from a fault, because a fault impedance also lies inside both characteristics.
"If the point leaves the outer zone, a trip is permitted (no power swing)." Misleading. Leaving the outer characteristic resets the swing detection after a reset delay, so that ordinary fault protection is restored once the swing has passed. It does not by itself permit a trip. Faults that occur during a swing need dedicated unblocking logic, described in Section 8.
"The relay does not trip during a power swing while the point is inside the outer zone." Only for the zones that have been selected for blocking, and only until an unblocking condition is detected. Many utilities block zone 2 and higher but leave zone 1 or pilot zones selectively unblocked, and every scheme must still trip for a fault during the swing.
"Power swing blocking prevents tripping during stable swings while maintaining fault protection." That is the goal, but blocking alone does not deal with unstable swings. If the swing is unstable, PSB can keep the system from separating where it should. The design must decide where out-of-step tripping is applied and where blocking is applied.
"Settings depend on the system study." Correct and important. Swing characteristics, timers and unblocking settings must come from stability simulations covering the fastest credible slip frequency, the most severe stable swings and the load encroachment limit. Generic settings are a common audit finding and a common cause of misoperation.
"Power swings are oscillations of active power between areas." Correct, with an addition: the voltage magnitudes oscillate too. The voltage at the electrical center falls toward zero as the angle approaches 180 degrees, which is why swing-center voltage is itself a powerful detection signal.
"The shape of the measuring zone depends on whether mho or polygonal is selected." Correct, and it matters for PRC-026. A large mho characteristic usually encroaches further toward the swing locus than a quadrilateral with resistive blinders, as Worked Example 2 shows.

Eight findings for decision makers

1. The electrical center decides who sees the swing. Relays on lines that contain, or are close to, the electrical center of a credible swing see impedance deep inside their zones. A line far from the center may never see the swing at all.

2. Zone 2 and zone 3 are usually the problem, not zone 1. Large mho reaches cover more of the swing locus. In our 345 kV example, an 80% zone 1 passes the PRC-026 screening while a 125% zone 2 mho fails it.

3. Timer and characteristic spacing are linked. A 17-degree spacing between swing characteristics gives 2.8 cycles of travel time at 1 Hz slip but only 0.7 cycle at 4 Hz. Fast swings require wider spacing, which competes with load encroachment.

4. Faults during swings are the hardest case. Unblocking logic for unbalanced faults is mature. Three-phase faults during a swing need dedicated methods and are the main reason modern relays added continuous and swing-center-voltage algorithms.

5. Blocking and tripping must be planned together. A system where every line is blocked cannot separate when it must. Out-of-step tripping belongs at planned separation points chosen from studies.

6. PRC-026 is evidence driven. Compliance depends on the Planning Coordinator's notifications, the relay owner's documented evaluation against the Attachment B criteria and, where needed, a Corrective Action Plan that is tracked to completion.

7. Inverter-based resources change swing behavior. IBR-heavy areas can have less inertia, different voltage behavior during swings and power oscillations driven by controls. Relays and studies must account for them.

8. Good settings come from a single model. The stability model, the short-circuit model and the relay settings must use the same impedances and the same operating cases, or the evaluation will not stand up to scrutiny.

Key terms

Term Meaning
Apparent impedance The ratio of measured voltage to measured current at the relay location, plotted on the R–X plane.
Power swing A variation in power flow caused by changes in the relative angles of generator rotors after a disturbance.
Stable power swing A swing in which the angle reaches a maximum and returns, so that synchronism is maintained.
Unstable power swing / out of step A swing in which the angle continues to increase and the systems lose synchronism. Also called pole slipping.
Electrical center The point in the system where voltage is zero when the angle between the equivalent sources is 180 degrees.
Slip frequency The rate of change of the angle between the two systems, in hertz (360 degrees per second equals 1 Hz).
Power swing blocking (PSB) Logic that blocks selected distance elements while a swing is detected.
Out-of-step tripping (OST) Logic that trips selected breakers when an unstable swing is detected.
Trip on the way in / trip on the way out OST that trips as the impedance enters the inner characteristic, or after it has passed through and is leaving.
Swing-center voltage (SCV) An estimate of the voltage at the electrical center, approximately the local voltage times the cosine of the angle between voltage and current.
Load-responsive protective relay A relay that can respond to load current, such as phase distance, phase overcurrent and out-of-step elements, as used in NERC PRC-023 and PRC-026.
Unstable power swing region The region of the R–X plane defined in PRC-026 Attachment B, based on a system separation angle of 120 degrees and a range of source voltage ratios.

Part B — Engineering Guide to Power Swing Protection and PRC-026

1. The physics of a power swing

1.1 Two-source model

The simplest useful model of a power swing is two Thévenin sources connected by a transmission line. The sending-end source E_S sits behind impedance Z_S, the line has impedance Z_L, and the receiving-end source E_R sits behind Z_R. The total transfer impedance is Z_T = Z_S + Z_L + Z_R. For a mainly reactive system, active power transfer follows the familiar relation:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 1

where δ is the angle by which E_S leads E_R. Rotor dynamics follow the swing equation, written per unit on the machine base:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 2

H is the inertia constant in seconds, ω_s the synchronous speed in electrical radians per second, P_m the mechanical power and P_e the electrical power. When a fault depresses P_e, the machine accelerates and δ increases. When the fault clears, P_e rises above P_m, the machine decelerates, and if the decelerating energy is enough, δ reaches a maximum and swings back. This is the equal-area criterion, and it links the protection engineer's clearing times directly to whether a swing is stable.

1.2 Slip frequency

The rate at which the angle changes is the slip frequency:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 3

A slip of 1 Hz means the angle advances 360 degrees per second, or 6 degrees per 60 Hz cycle. Stable swings between large interconnected areas are slow, often 0.1 to 1 Hz near their maximum angle (the angle stops and reverses, so the instantaneous slip passes through zero). Unstable swings speed up as the systems pull apart. Slip frequencies of 2 to 5 Hz are commonly assumed for setting purposes on transmission systems, and slips of 5 to 7 Hz or more can occur close to a small, low-inertia generating plant losing synchronism with a large system. The design slip frequency is a study result, not a constant.

1.3 Power swings from more than two sources

Real systems have many machines and the swing is rarely a clean two-source oscillation. Inter-area modes between large regions are typically in the 0.1 to 1 Hz range. Local plant modes, where one plant swings against the rest of the system, are typically 1 to 2 Hz. Control interactions, including inverter-based resource controls, can produce oscillations at other frequencies. The two-source model remains the right tool for understanding relay behavior, because at any one relay the system can be reduced to equivalent sources on each side, but the equivalents change with the operating case and the contingency. That is why PRC-026 relies on studies rather than a single calculation.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel builds and maintains PSS/E, PSLF and PSCAD models for transmission owners, generator owners and developers, and uses them to quantify swing angles, slip frequencies and swing modes for the specific lines and plants our clients protect. We reduce those studies to the equivalent source impedances and slip-frequency ranges that relay engineers actually need.

2. What a distance relay sees during a swing

2.1 Apparent impedance during a swing

With the relay at the sending-end bus looking into the line, the voltage at the relay is V = E_S − I·Z_S and the current is I = (E_S − E_R)/Z_T. Writing the voltage ratio as n = |E_S|/|E_R|, the apparent impedance is:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 4

For equal source magnitudes (n = 1), this simplifies to:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 5

Read this geometrically. The term Z_T/2 − Z_S is a fixed point halfway along the total system impedance. The second term moves along a line perpendicular to Z_T. As δ increases from small values toward 180 degrees, cot(δ/2) falls from large values toward zero and the apparent impedance travels along the perpendicular bisector of the total system impedance, crossing it exactly at δ = 180 degrees. For n ≠ 1, the locus becomes a circle. When E_S > E_R the circle bulges toward the receiving end, and when E_S < E_R it bulges toward the sending end.

2.2 The electrical center

At δ = 180 degrees with equal sources, the voltage at the midpoint of Z_T is zero. That point is the electrical center. If it falls on a protected line, the relays at both ends see an impedance on their own line, inside zone 1, at the instant the angle passes 180 degrees. If the electrical center lies in a source behind the relay, the relay sees the swing in the reverse direction or not at all.

The location of the electrical center moves with the source impedances. Strengthening the sending end (smaller Z_S) or weakening the receiving end moves the center toward the receiving end. Unequal voltages move it as well. Planning studies must therefore look at the range of credible operating cases.

2.3 Worked Example 1 — Swing locus on a 345 kV line

System. A 100-mile, 345 kV line with positive-sequence impedance 0.58 Ω per mile at 85 degrees, giving Z_L = 58 Ω at 85 degrees primary. Equivalent source impedances at the line angle are Z_S = 20 Ω at the sending end and Z_R = 25 Ω at the receiving end. The total system impedance is Z_T = 103 Ω at 85 degrees. These are typical, illustrative values; a real evaluation uses the Planning Coordinator's equivalents.

Equal sources. Applying the n = 1 equation gives:

Angle δ Apparent impedance (primary Ω) Magnitude Angle
60° 91.6 + j23.6 94.6 Ω 14.4°
90° 54.0 + j26.9 60.4 Ω 26.5°
120° 32.4 + j28.8 43.3 Ω 41.7°
150° 16.5 + j30.2 34.4 Ω 61.3°
180° 2.7 + j31.4 31.5 Ω 85.0°

Electrical center. Z_T/2 − Z_S = 51.5 − 20 = 31.5 Ω along the line angle, which is 54% of the way down the line. It is on the protected line, inside an 80% zone 1 reach of 46.4 Ω. If this system ever slips poles across this line, zone 1 at both terminals will see it.

Unequal sources. With E_S/E_R = 0.8, the locus crosses the line impedance at 25.8 Ω at 180 degrees; with 1.25, it crosses at 37.2 Ω. The electrical center moves about ±6 Ω with a ±20 to 25% voltage ratio change.

What this tells the protection engineer. At 90 degrees the swing impedance of 60.4 Ω at 26.5 degrees is outside most zone 1 and zone 2 characteristics but close to large mho zones. At 120 degrees, 43.3 Ω at 41.7 degrees is inside a 125% zone 2 mho. A stable swing that reaches 120 degrees would therefore enter zone 2 on this line. Figure 1 shows the loci, the zones and the swing characteristics on one diagram.

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 6

Figure 1. R–X diagram for the 345 kV example: zone 1 and zone 2 mho characteristics, a zone 2 quadrilateral, inner and outer power swing characteristics, swing loci for three source voltage ratios, the maximum load point used for PRC-023, and a screening region based on a 120-degree separation angle and a 0.7 to 1.43 voltage ratio range (Keentel approximation of the PRC-026 Attachment B construction; see Section 11).

How Keentel Engineering helps here. For each line we evaluate, Keentel plots the relay's actual characteristics, as set, against the swing loci from the Planning Coordinator's equivalents and from our own dynamic simulations. The result is a single diagram, like Figure 1, that a protection engineer, a planner and an auditor can all read.

3. Why unwanted trips during swings matter

3.1 Consequences of tripping on a stable swing

When a line trips during a stable swing, the transfer impedance between the swinging groups increases. The maximum power that can be transferred falls, the decelerating area shrinks, and a swing that would have been stable can become unstable. The next line then sees a larger swing, and the process can cascade. Unwanted trips also remove transmission paths that operators are relying on for post-contingency flows and voltage support.

3.2 Consequences of not separating an unstable swing

If the swing is unstable, two parts of the system are running at different frequencies. Every slip cycle drives voltage at the electrical center to zero, causes large current and power pulsations, stresses generator shafts and windings, and can trip load on undervoltage. Generators near the electrical center may trip on their own out-of-step or loss-of-field protection, which removes generation unpredictably. The system must be separated, preferably into islands with a reasonable balance of load and generation so that underfrequency load shedding and governors can recover.

3.3 Lessons from major disturbances

NERC and regional entities have reviewed many disturbances where relays responded to swings. Recurring findings include zone 3 and other long-reach elements operating during stable or unstable swings and stressed, low-voltage conditions; relays at locations near the electrical center tripping before planned separation schemes could act; and inconsistent application of power swing blocking. These findings drove NERC's technical work on power swings and the development of PRC-026, alongside PRC-023 for relay loadability.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel's event analysis team reviews relay oscillography, sequence-of-events data and phasor measurement data after disturbances to determine whether a trip was caused by a fault, a stable swing or an unstable swing. That determination is the trigger for the PRC-026 Requirement R2 clock, as discussed in Section 11.

4. Power swing blocking: purpose and principles

4.1 What blocking does

Power swing blocking (PSB) detects a swing and blocks the tripping of selected distance elements for as long as the swing lasts, or until an unblock condition or a timer releases the block. The elements typically considered for blocking are zone 2 and zone 3 phase distance elements, and often zone 1 and communication-assisted zones, depending on the utility's philosophy. Ground distance elements are often blocked as well, although they are less affected by balanced swings because their residual compensation and polarization respond differently.

4.2 What blocking does not do

Blocking does not identify whether the swing is stable. A blocked relay sits quietly through a stable swing, which is correct, and also through an unstable swing, which may not be. Separation for unstable swings must be provided by out-of-step tripping at chosen locations or by generator out-of-step protection. Blocking also creates a risk: if a fault occurs while the relay is blocked, the relay must still trip, and quickly. That is why unblocking logic (Section 8) is a mandatory part of any PSB design.

4.3 Where blocking is applied

A common philosophy is:

  • block distance elements on lines that are not designated separation points, so that stable swings do not trip them;
  • apply out-of-step tripping at designated separation points, with blocking of other elements at those locations until the trip decision is made;
  • apply generator out-of-step protection (device 78) at plants that are likely to slip poles relative to the system;
  • block reclosing during swings, so that a breaker does not reclose across a large angle.

The choice of separation points belongs to planning engineers and is documented in system studies and operating procedures. The relay settings must follow that choice.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel prepares system-wide power swing blocking and out-of-step tripping philosophies for transmission owners: which lines block, which lines trip, which zones are blocked, and how reclosing is supervised. We write the philosophy in a form that maps directly to settings and to PRC-026 evidence.

5. Classic detection: concentric characteristics and timing

5.1 Principle

Classic detection uses two characteristics around the distance zones: an outer characteristic and an inner characteristic. Both may be quadrilaterals with resistive blinders parallel to the line angle, concentric mho circles or a combination. The relay starts a timer when the impedance crosses the outer characteristic and stops it when the impedance crosses the inner characteristic.

  • If the traverse takes longer than the set time ΔT, the movement is slow, which is typical of a swing. The relay declares a swing and asserts the blocking signal.
  • If the traverse takes less than ΔT, the movement is fast, typical of a fault, which moves the impedance from the load point to the fault point in about one cycle or less. The relay does not declare a swing, and the distance elements operate normally.

The swing condition is held while the impedance stays inside the outer characteristic. When it leaves the outer characteristic, or after a maximum blocking time, the swing detection resets after a short reset delay. This is the logic often summarized as "inside the outer zone means swing; leaving the outer zone permits tripping". The accurate statement is that crossing slowly means swing, and leaving resets detection so that normal protection is restored.

5.2 Geometry of the characteristics

For blinders parallel to the line angle, the perpendicular distance d⊥ between the equal-source swing locus crossing point and the line through the system impedance is related to the angle by:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 7

So a blinder placed at perpendicular offset d is crossed by an equal-source swing at the angle:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 8

The time spent traveling between an outer blinder at angle δ_out and an inner blinder at angle δ_in is:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 9

This gives the fundamental setting trade-off. The inner characteristic must enclose the largest distance zone that is to be blocked, with margin, so the swing is detected before any blocked zone picks up. The outer characteristic must stay clear of the maximum load impedance. The spacing between them must give enough travel time at the fastest swing to exceed ΔT, and ΔT must be longer than the time a fault takes to cross, including filter transients.

5.3 Worked Example 3 — Setting the characteristics and the timer

Continue with the 345 kV line. Suppose the zone 2 quadrilateral has resistive blinders at ±20 Ω. Place the inner power swing characteristic at ±25 Ω and the outer at ±35 Ω, both parallel to the line angle.

Using the blinder equation with |Z_T| = 103 Ω:

Characteristic Offset Swing angle at crossing
Inner 25 Ω 128.2°
Outer 35 Ω 111.6°
Spacing 10 Ω 16.6°

Travel time between them:

Slip frequency Travel time Cycles at 60 Hz
0.5 Hz 92 ms 5.5
1 Hz 46 ms 2.8
2 Hz 23 ms 1.4
4 Hz 11.5 ms 0.69
7 Hz 6.6 ms 0.40

Interpretation. A ΔT of 1 cycle would detect swings up to about 2.8 Hz. A faster swing would cross in less than 1 cycle and be treated as a fault, so blocking would fail and the zones would trip. If studies show credible slips up to 5 Hz, the spacing must be about 30 degrees for a 1-cycle timer (5 Hz × 360° / 60 = 30°). Keeping the inner characteristic at 25 Ω (128.2°), the outer must move to about 44.6 Ω (98.2°).

Check against load (Worked Example 5 below). At a 2,000 A rating the PRC-023 load point is 46.2 Ω from the line axis, which leaves only 1.6 Ω between the widened outer characteristic and load. That margin is too small for the measurement and voltage-angle uncertainties. The engineer must either accept a lower detectable slip, tighten the zone 2 resistive reach so the inner characteristic can move in, use load-encroachment shaping, or use a detection method that does not depend on fixed spacing (Section 6).

5.4 The timer must exceed the fault traverse time

A fault moves the apparent impedance almost instantaneously, but the relay's phasor filter takes time to settle, typically about one cycle for a full-cycle filter. During that transient the calculated impedance travels along a path from the load point to the fault point. If ΔT is shorter than the filter's settling time, a fault could be mistaken for a swing and blocked. Many utilities therefore use ΔT values from about 1.5 to 4 cycles, depending on the filter design, and widen the characteristics accordingly. The relay manufacturer's guidance on minimum ΔT for its filter must be followed.

5.5 Worked Example 5 — Load encroachment limit on the outer characteristic

NERC PRC-023 requires that phase protective relays not trip at 150% of the highest seasonal 4-hour Facility Rating with 0.85 per-unit voltage and a 30-degree load angle, under its R1.1 criterion. The equivalent minimum load impedance is:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 10

For the 345 kV line, V_LN = 199.2 kV.

Rating MVA Z_load at 30° Resistive component Perpendicular offset from line axis
1,600 A 956 70.5 Ω 61.1 Ω 57.8 Ω
2,000 A 1,195 56.4 Ω 48.9 Ω 46.2 Ω

For blinders parallel to the line, the relevant quantity is the perpendicular offset of the load point from the line axis, not its resistance. With a 35 Ω outer characteristic, both ratings leave comfortable margin. With the 44.6 Ω outer characteristic needed for 5 Hz detection, the 2,000 A rating leaves almost none. PRC-023 applies to phase distance elements; it is not written for power swing characteristics, but a power swing characteristic that picks up on heavy load will assert blocking during normal operation, which is unacceptable. Keentel treats the PRC-023 load point as a hard limit for the outer characteristic with a margin of at least 10 to 20%.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel calculates swing traverse times from study-based slip frequencies, checks the result against the relay's filter and timer guidance, and checks the outer characteristic against PRC-023 load points. When the constraints conflict, we present the options and the residual risk in writing so that the owner can make an informed decision.

6. Modern detection methods

Fixed concentric characteristics need system-specific settings and can be hard to fit between the largest zone and the load region on long, heavily loaded lines. Numerical relays now offer additional detection methods, often in combination.

6.1 Continuous impedance-rate methods

Instead of timing a crossing between two boundaries, the relay tracks the apparent impedance every processing interval and evaluates its rate of change and the smoothness of its trajectory. A swing produces a continuous, smooth, roughly monotonic path with a rate of change that is bounded by the slip frequency. A fault produces a jump. Some implementations also check that resistance changes continuously in one direction (sometimes called R-dot or ΔR/Δt supervision) and that the trajectory is consistent in all three phases. These methods need fewer system-specific settings and can detect swings with higher slip frequencies, but they still need a region in which they operate, usually tied to the largest zone.

6.2 Swing-center voltage methods

The swing-center voltage (SCV) is the voltage at the electrical center of a two-source system. For equal sources of magnitude E:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 11

A relay cannot measure the voltage at the electrical center directly, but it can estimate it from local quantities. For a system where the line and source impedances are mainly reactive, the projection of the local voltage on the local current is a good estimate:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 12

where φ is the angle between local voltage and current. During a swing, SCV changes smoothly between about 1 per unit and zero. Its rate of change is:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 13

A swing gives a continuous, bounded rate of change, while a fault gives a step. SCV methods are largely independent of the source and line impedances, which makes them attractive where system equivalents vary widely. They are less dependent on characteristic spacing and can detect fast swings.

6.3 Worked Example 4 — Swing-center voltage

For equal 1.0 per-unit sources:

Angle δ SCV = cos(δ/2)
0° 1.00 pu
60° 0.87 pu
90° 0.71 pu
120° 0.50 pu
150° 0.26 pu
180° 0.00 pu

The 120-degree point used in PRC-026 corresponds to a swing-center voltage of 0.5 per unit. Figure 2 shows a single-machine simulation (Worked Example 7) in which a 4-cycle fault produces a stable swing, with swing-center voltage staying above about 0.88 pu, while a 16-cycle fault produces an out-of-step condition in which swing-center voltage repeatedly falls to zero.

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 14

Figure 2. Single-machine example: electrical power and swing-center voltage for a stable swing (fault cleared in 4 cycles) and an out-of-step condition (fault cleared in 16 cycles). Illustrative model with H = 4 s and no damping.

6.4 Other approaches

Other methods include monitoring the pattern of current magnitude and power over successive cycles, using the rate of change of active and reactive power, and using synchrophasor measurements from both ends of a line or from wide-area systems to measure angle directly. Wide-area angle measurement is used in some special protection systems for controlled separation. These methods are complementary, and modern relays often combine two methods for security.

6.5 Choosing a method
Method Strengths Limitations
Concentric characteristics with timer Well understood; easy to test; transparent at audit Needs equivalent impedances and slip frequency; spacing competes with load; fast swings can be missed
Continuous impedance rate Fewer settings; better for fast swings Logic varies by relay; testing needs dynamic test sequences
Swing-center voltage rate Largely independent of system impedances; good for fast swings Accuracy reduces where the system is not mainly reactive or where the electrical center is far from the relay
Synchrophasor or wide-area angle Measures angle directly; ideal for planned separation Depends on communications; mainly used for special schemes, not line-by-line blocking

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel selects the detection method, or combination of methods, that fits each line's impedance, loading and slip range. We then verify it with playback of simulated swings and faults-during-swings from EMT or RMS studies, using the relay's own test tools, before settings are issued.

7. Out-of-step tripping

7.1 Purpose

Out-of-step tripping (OST) separates the system when a swing is unstable. It should operate only at locations chosen in planning studies, where separation leaves islands that can survive, and it should open breakers at a time when the voltage across the breaker contacts is within the breaker's capability.

7.2 Detecting an unstable swing

A swing that crosses the outer and inner characteristics slowly and then continues across the impedance plane and exits on the opposite side has passed through 180 degrees. That is the signature of loss of synchronism. Classic OST logic therefore uses the same concentric characteristics as PSB but requires the impedance to traverse the whole characteristic, entering from one side and leaving from the other. Swing-center voltage methods detect the same event as SCV passing through zero and reversing sign. Continuous methods detect it as a trajectory that crosses the line impedance axis.

7.3 Trip on the way in versus trip on the way out
Approach How it works Advantages Disadvantages
Trip on the way in Trips as soon as the swing is judged unstable, typically when the impedance reaches the inner characteristic with a slow traverse Separates earlier; shorter disturbance; less voltage dip for customers Must be sure the swing is unstable; breakers may open with the angle approaching 180°, the highest voltage across contacts
Trip on the way out Waits until the impedance has passed through the line axis and is leaving the inner or outer characteristic Certainty that synchronism has been lost; breakers open with the angle moving away from 180° One full slip passes before separation; more stress on generators and system

The breaker opening angle matters because, for equal 1.0 per-unit sources, the voltage across an open breaker is:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 15

At 180 degrees this is 2.0 per unit, the out-of-phase condition. IEEE C37 breaker standards assign out-of-phase switching ratings with reduced interrupting current and specific transient recovery voltage requirements, and not every breaker is rated or tested for out-of-phase switching at the full system voltage. Protection and breaker specifications must be checked together.

7.4 Worked Example 6 — Breaker opening angle

Assumptions. Slip frequency 2 Hz, total trip time including relay, auxiliary and breaker operation of 3 cycles (50 ms). Angle advance during the trip time: 360° × 2 Hz × 0.05 s = 36°.

Trip initiated at Angle at contact separation Voltage across breaker
90° (way in) 126° 1.78 pu
120° (way in) 156° 1.96 pu
240° (way out) 276° 1.34 pu

Tripping on the way out at 240 degrees reduces the voltage across the contacts from almost 2.0 per unit to about 1.34 per unit in this example. Where trip-on-the-way-in is required to limit the disturbance, the breaker's out-of-phase capability must be confirmed. These figures are idealized: real TRV depends on the system on each side, and breaker manufacturers' out-of-phase ratings govern.

7.5 Estimating slip from a recorded traverse

If a fault recorder or relay event shows the impedance took 3 cycles (50 ms) to travel between characteristics 16.6 degrees apart, the slip at that point was 16.6° / (360° × 0.05 s) ≈ 0.92 Hz. Repeating this for several events gives a measured distribution of slip frequencies that can validate, or challenge, the study-based setting.

7.6 Generator out-of-step protection

Generators that can slip poles relative to the system are protected by out-of-step (device 78) relays, commonly using mho and blinder schemes that look into the generator and its step-up transformer. IEEE C37.102 gives guidance. Generator out-of-step protection must be coordinated with transmission OST: a generator should be tripped when it is the generator that is out of step, while the transmission system should be separated when two areas lose synchronism. Generator relays are also within PRC-026 applicability where they are load-responsive and on identified Elements.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel designs out-of-step tripping schemes at planned separation points, checks breaker out-of-phase capability with the transmission owner's equipment data, and coordinates transmission OST with generator 78 relays. We document the separation philosophy alongside the island load-generation balance from the planning study.

8. Faults during a power swing: unblocking logic

8.1 Why this is the critical design issue

While a relay is blocked, a fault on the protected line must still be cleared, typically within the time required by stability and equipment limits. Faults during swings are not rare: the fault that started the swing may evolve, a second fault may occur, or a flashover may result from conductor sag or galloping during the disturbance. A PSB design that cannot unblock reliably will turn a manageable event into a delayed clearing event.

8.2 Unbalanced faults

Unbalanced faults produce negative-sequence and, for ground faults, zero-sequence current. A balanced swing produces almost none. Unblocking logic therefore commonly releases the block when:

  • negative-sequence current exceeds a ratio of positive-sequence current (for example, I2/I1 above a set ratio), or
  • zero-sequence current exceeds a threshold or ratio, indicating a ground fault.

The ratios must be set above the unbalance produced by the swing itself, by untransposed lines and by open poles during single-pole tripping. During single-pole open intervals, sequence-based unblocking must be supervised or the open-phase condition will appear as unbalance.

8.3 Three-phase faults

A three-phase fault during a swing is balanced and produces no negative-sequence or zero-sequence current, so sequence methods cannot detect it. Relays use other indicators:

  • a sudden change in impedance trajectory or a jump in the rate of change of resistance or swing-center voltage, which a swing cannot produce;
  • a swing-center voltage that stays near zero for longer than a swing would allow, because a swing passes through zero but a three-phase fault holds the voltage low;
  • a low-voltage, low-power-factor test at the relay, often combined with a timer.

Where these indicators are not available or are not secure, a fallback is an unblock timer: if the impedance stays inside the inner characteristic for longer than any credible swing would (for example, 0.5 to 2 seconds, set from studies), the block is released. This is slow, and its effect on stability must be studied.

8.4 Faults in the remote system during swings

A fault outside the protected line during a swing should not unblock the relay at this terminal unless the fault is within a blocked zone that is intended to trip. Unblocking logic must therefore be combined with directional and zone supervision so that a remote unbalanced fault does not release a long-reach zone.

8.5 Pilot schemes during swings

In permissive overreaching transfer trip (POTT), directional comparison blocking (DCB) and directional comparison unblocking (DCUB) schemes, both terminals' overreaching elements may see a swing. Blocking must be applied consistently at both ends. In DCB schemes, a swing-induced carrier start at one end and not the other can cause a misoperation. Line current differential protection is inherently immune to power swings, because a swing is a through condition, which is one reason it is increasingly used on critical lines, with distance elements as backup.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel tests unblocking logic with study-based sequences of faults during swings: unbalanced faults at several points in the swing, three-phase faults near 180 degrees, evolving faults and single-pole open intervals. We review pilot scheme logic at both terminals together, because a scheme that is correct at one end and wrong at the other will misoperate.

9. Stable versus unstable swings and the link to clearing times

9.1 Worked Example 7 — Single-machine stability check

System. A generator delivering 1.0 per unit mechanical power with H = 4 s. Peak electrical power capability is 2.0 per unit before the fault, 0.5 per unit during the fault and 1.6 per unit after the fault clears with one line removed.

Equal-area criterion. The initial angle is δ_0 = arcsin(1.0/2.0) = 30°. The maximum angle on the post-fault curve is δ_max = 180° − arcsin(1.0/1.6) = 141.3°. The critical clearing angle follows from:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 16

which gives δ_cr = 76.3°. Integrating the swing equation shows a critical clearing time of about 0.222 s, or 13.3 cycles.

Implications.

  • Cleared in 4 cycles, the first swing peaks at about 57 degrees. This is a stable swing, well below 120 degrees, and should not trip line relays.
  • Cleared in 16 cycles (beyond the critical time), the machine slips poles. Swing-center voltage falls to zero every slip cycle, as Figure 2 shows, and out-of-step protection must act.
  • Delayed clearing of a stuck breaker, often 10 to 15 cycles including breaker failure time, sits close to the critical time in this example. That is the case where the relay engineer and the planner must work together, because both the swing and its detection depend on clearing time.
9.2 Why PRC-026 uses 120 degrees

The PRC-026 Attachment B criteria use a system separation angle of 120 degrees as the boundary for evaluating whether a relay could trip on a stable swing. The rationale, set out in NERC's technical work on power swings, is that stable swings rarely exceed about 120 degrees, so a relay characteristic that is only entered beyond 120 degrees would see only swings that are, in practice, unstable. A relay that would operate for swings below 120 degrees is at risk of tripping on stable swings.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel links clearing-time studies to protection settings: we identify the cases where delayed clearing produces swings close to the 120-degree boundary and verify that PSB, OST and zone timers behave correctly in exactly those cases.

10. Inverter-based resources and power swings

10.1 What changes in IBR-heavy areas

Inverter-based resources (solar, wind and battery storage) change power swing behavior in several ways:

  • Less synchronous inertia. Local swing modes can be faster, and slip frequencies during instability can be higher.
  • Current-limited fault contribution. IBR plants supply limited fault current, often close to rated current, with controlled sequence content. Equivalent source impedances behind relays become nonlinear and operating-point dependent.
  • Control-driven power oscillations. Plant controllers, phase-locked loops and grid-following current controls can create or amplify oscillations, including sub-synchronous control interaction near series-compensated lines.
  • Voltage-dependent behavior. During deep voltage dips, IBRs may move to reactive current priority, reduce active power or enter momentary cessation (where permitted), which changes the apparent impedance trajectory seen by nearby line relays.
  • Grid-forming resources. Grid-forming inverters behave more like voltage sources behind impedance and can participate in swings in a way that resembles synchronous machines, but with current limits that change their behavior during large swings.
10.2 Implications for detection

Concentric-characteristic methods assume trajectories governed by synchronous machine dynamics. In IBR-dominated areas, trajectories can be less regular, with control-driven changes in rate. Swing-center voltage methods remain useful but may need validation with EMT simulations that represent the actual inverter controls. Unblocking logic based on negative-sequence current must account for IBR negative-sequence injection as required by IEEE 2800-2022, which differs from the behavior of synchronous machines.

10.3 PRC-026 applicability for IBR plants

The interconnection line, main power transformer and other BES Elements at an IBR plant can be identified by the Planning Coordinator if studies show tripping on swings. Load-responsive relays on those Elements, such as distance relays on the generator tie line and overcurrent relays on the main power transformer, then fall under the Generator Owner's PRC-026 obligations. IBR owners should also coordinate PRC-026 work with PRC-024 and PRC-029 ride-through settings and PRC-030 event analysis.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel runs PSCAD EMT studies of IBR plants and their interconnections with vendor-specific inverter and plant controller models, extracts the apparent impedance seen by nearby line relays during swings and faults, and checks detection and unblocking logic against those trajectories. Our related blogs on weak-grid inverter stability, IBR negative-sequence behavior and LVRT-to-HVRT events explain the underlying control behavior.

11. NERC PRC-026: relay performance during stable power swings

11.1 Purpose and history

NERC Reliability Standard PRC-026-1, Relay Performance During Stable Power Swings , was approved by FERC in Order No. 818 and became enforceable in phases between 2018 and 2020. Its purpose is to ensure that load-responsive protective relays are expected to not trip in response to stable power swings during non-fault conditions. It complements PRC-023 (transmission relay loadability) and PRC-025 (generator relay loadability), which deal with steady-state load, by addressing the dynamic case of a swing. PRC-026-1 is the version in effect at the time of writing; entities should confirm the current version and its effective dates on NERC's website before relying on any detail below.

11.2 Applicability
Item Applicability
Functional entities Planning Coordinators (R1), Generator Owners and Transmission Owners (R2 to R4)
Facilities Load-responsive protective relays, as defined in Attachment A, applied at the terminals of generator, transformer and transmission line BES Elements
Relays typically included Phase distance, phase overcurrent, out-of-step tripping and loss-of-field elements, where they can respond to swing conditions
Relays typically excluded Attachment A lists exclusions such as elements supervised by power swing blocking, elements enabled only when other systems fail (for example, on loss of potential), elements associated with DC lines and DC converter transformers, and certain fault detector and switch-onto-fault elements. Confirm the full list against the current text.
11.3 Requirements in brief
Requirement Who What
R1 Planning Coordinator At least once each calendar year, notify the Generator Owner and Transmission Owner of each generator, transformer and transmission line BES Element that meets one or more criteria: (1) Elements associated with generators where an angular stability constraint is addressed by a System Operating Limit or Remedial Action Scheme; (2) Elements monitored as part of an SOL based on an angular stability constraint; (3) Elements forming the boundary of an island in the most recent UFLS design assessment where the island is formed by tripping due to angular instability; (4) Elements where the most recent annual Planning Assessment shows relay tripping due to a stable or unstable power swing during a simulated disturbance.
R2 Generator Owner, Transmission Owner Within 12 full calendar months of an R1 notification (where an Attachment B evaluation has not been performed in the last five calendar years), or within 12 full calendar months of becoming aware that an Element tripped in response to a stable or unstable power swing due to its protective relays, determine whether the load-responsive protective relays on that Element meet the Attachment B criteria.
R3 Generator Owner, Transmission Owner Within six full calendar months of determining that a relay does not meet Attachment B, develop a Corrective Action Plan (CAP) so that the Protection System meets Attachment B, or is excluded under Attachment A (for example, by adding power swing blocking), while maintaining dependable fault detection and dependable out-of-step tripping where OST is applied.
R4 Generator Owner, Transmission Owner Implement each CAP and update it if actions or timetables change, until completed.

The wording above summarizes the requirements. The binding text, measures and violation severity levels are in the standard itself, and an entity's compliance program should quote them directly.

11.4 Attachment B criteria

Attachment B sets out the tests. In outline:

  • Criterion A (impedance-based relays). An impedance relay used for tripping is expected not to trip for a stable power swing when its characteristic is completely contained within the unstable power swing region. That region is formed from the union of shapes in the R–X plane: a lower loss-of-synchronism circle based on a sending-to-receiving voltage ratio of 0.7, an upper loss-of-synchronism circle based on a ratio of 1.43, and a lens connecting the endpoints of the total system impedance, formed by a constant system separation angle of 120 degrees with varying source voltage ratios. The total system impedance is calculated under the conditions specified in the standard, including the source impedances and the treatment of parallel transfer paths.
  • Criterion B (overcurrent relays). The pickup of an overcurrent element used for tripping must be above the current calculated for a stable swing at a system separation angle of 120 degrees, with the source voltages specified in the standard (commonly applied as 1.05 per unit at both ends), again under the specified system conditions.

The practical meaning is simple: a relay passes if it can only see a swing that has already passed the 120-degree boundary, and fails if a swing below 120 degrees can enter its tripping characteristic.

11.5 A practical screening method

Keentel's screening uses the same apparent impedance relationships as Section 2. For any point Z on a relay characteristic, define W = (Z + Z_S)/Z_T. The source voltage ratio and angle that would place the swing impedance at that point are:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 17

A point is in the screening region if the implied angle is at least 120 degrees or the implied voltage ratio is outside 0.7 to 1.43. A characteristic passes if every point on its boundary is in the region. This reproduces the shapes described in Attachment B for a two-source equivalent and lets us scan a characteristic in a few seconds. Formal evaluations follow the exact construction in the standard, using the Planning Coordinator's source impedances, and are documented with plots.

11.6 Worked Example 2 — Attachment B screening on the 345 kV line

Mho characteristics. Using the screening method on the 345 kV system from Worked Example 1, the smallest implied separation angle on the boundary of each mho characteristic (within the 0.7 to 1.43 ratio range) is:

Mho reach (85° maximum torque angle) Reach Minimum angle on boundary Screening result
80% (zone 1) 46.4 Ω 130.1° Pass
100% 58.0 Ω 121.1° Pass, marginal
125% (zone 2) 72.5 Ω 108.8° Fail
150% 87.0 Ω 96.7° Fail
180% (long zone 3) 104.4 Ω 85.4° Fail

The largest mho reach that passes in this system is about 59.4 Ω, or about 102% of the line. Zone 2 at 125% fails because its right-hand side is entered by a swing at about 109 degrees.

Quadrilateral alternative. A zone 2 quadrilateral with the same 72.5 Ω reactive reach but resistive blinders parallel to the line:

Resistive blinder Minimum angle on boundary Screening result
±10 Ω 157.4° Pass
±15 Ω 146.6° Pass
±20 Ω 136.3° Pass
±30 Ω 117.6° Fail

Options for the failing zone 2 mho.

1. Replace the mho with a quadrilateral with resistive blinders of about ±20 Ω, if that still covers the expected fault resistance (check with the arc resistance and tower footing resistance analysis for the line).

2. Supervise zone 2 with power swing blocking that meets the Attachment A exclusion, while keeping dependable fault detection and unblocking for faults during swings.

3. Add a load-encroachment or lens shaping function that cuts the mho characteristic back from the swing locus, if the relay supports it.

4. Reduce the reach, if coordination with the remote bus and adjacent lines allows.

Overcurrent (Criterion B). For a phase overcurrent element on the same line, the swing current at 120 degrees with 1.05 per-unit sources is:

Keentel Power Swing Blocking PRC-026 original technical diagram or equation 18

A phase overcurrent element used for tripping on this Element would need a pickup above about 3,500 A primary to pass this screening. These are screening results on illustrative equivalents; a formal R2 evaluation uses the system conditions specified in Attachment B and the Planning Coordinator's data.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel evaluates every load-responsive element on each identified Element (phase distance zones, phase overcurrent, out-of-step and loss-of-field) against Attachment B, documents the result in a plot and a calculation sheet, and, where a relay fails, prepares CAP options with their effect on fault coverage, coordination and PRC-023 loadability.

12. Keentel's PRC-026 compliance services

PRC-026 compliance is a multi-party process. The Planning Coordinator identifies Elements, the Transmission Owner and Generator Owner evaluate relays and fix problems, and all three must keep evidence. Keentel supports each step for utilities, independent transmission companies, generator owners (synchronous and inverter-based), and developers acquiring operating assets.

Service What Keentel delivers Evidence produced
R1 support for Planning Coordinators Screening of TPL-001 dynamic results for relay tripping on stable and unstable swings; identification of Elements under the four R1 criteria; annual notification letters Study report, Element list with criteria, dated notifications
R1 data packages Thévenin source impedances, system separation conditions and operating cases for each identified Element, in a format relay owners can use directly Data transmittal records
R2 relay evaluations Retrieval and review of as-left relay settings; plotting of every load-responsive characteristic against the Attachment B region; overcurrent Criterion B checks Signed evaluation per Element and relay, plots, calculation sheets, date stamps against the 12-month clock
Event-driven R2 evaluations Analysis of trips to decide whether a stable or unstable power swing was involved; evaluation within 12 months of awareness Event analysis report, evaluation records
Settings database and characteristic library Structured database of relay settings, characteristics and evaluation status for all applicable Elements Database exports, change history
R3 Corrective Action Plans CAP options (re-shaping, quadrilateral conversion, power swing blocking, reach changes) with fault coverage, PRC-023 and coordination checks; recommended CAP with schedule CAP document dated within six months, approvals
R4 implementation support Settings files, test plans, field implementation support and closeout Implementation records, as-left settings, test results, CAP closure
Five-year re-evaluation tracking Calendar tracking of evaluations and notifications to avoid gaps Compliance calendar, reminders
Audit preparation Mock audits, Reliability Standard Audit Worksheet (RSAW) narratives, evidence indexing RSAW-ready evidence binder
Program integration Alignment with PRC-023, PRC-024, PRC-025, PRC-027, PRC-019, PRC-029, PRC-030, TPL-001 and MOD-032 work so that the same models and settings feed every program Cross-referenced compliance matrix
12.1 How we keep evaluations defensible
  • One model. We take source impedances from the same short-circuit and planning models used for PRC-027 coordination and TPL-001 studies, so that every compliance program uses consistent data.
  • As-left settings. We evaluate relays from the settings actually in the field, retrieved from the relay or the owner's settings management system, not from design intent.
  • Every load-responsive element. We list every element that can respond to swing conditions, including backup and time-delayed elements, and record why any element is excluded under Attachment A.
  • Clocks and dates. Every notification, evaluation and CAP has a date, a responsible person and a link to the triggering event, so auditors can follow the 12-month and six-month timelines.
  • Professional engineering review. Evaluations and CAPs are reviewed and approved by licensed professional engineers.
12.2 Common PRC-026 findings we resolve
Finding Typical root cause Keentel resolution
Zone 2 or zone 3 mho fails Attachment B Long reach and large mho circle near the swing locus Quadrilateral conversion, lens shaping or PSB supervision, with fault coverage verified
Evaluation used outdated source impedances Settings study separate from planning model Rebuild equivalents from current models; re-evaluate
No record of why elements were excluded Exclusions assumed, not documented Attachment A exclusion log for every element
Event-triggered evaluation missed Trip not recognized as swing related Event review procedure linking PRC-004 misoperation review and PRC-026 R2
CAP overdue No tracking, outage scheduling conflicts CAP tracker with milestones and status reporting
PSB enabled without unblocking checks PSB added to meet Attachment A, unblocking not tested Faults-during-swings test plan and settings review

13. Settings and study workflow

A complete power swing protection design and PRC-026 evaluation follows a repeatable workflow.

13.1 Step 1 — Gather system data
  • Positive-sequence line impedance from line constants calculations.
  • Source equivalents at each terminal for normal and contingency conditions, from the short-circuit model and the Planning Coordinator's data.
  • Facility ratings for PRC-023 loadability.
  • Dynamic simulation results: swing angles, slip frequencies and electrical center locations for the critical disturbances in the TPL-001 assessment.
  • Existing relay settings, as left in the field.
13.2 Step 2 — Locate the electrical center

Calculate the electrical center for each credible case. If it lies on the line or close to it, the line is a candidate for out-of-step tripping or for careful blocking. If it lies well behind either terminal, the line may see little of the swing.

13.3 Step 3 — Decide the philosophy for this line

Decide whether the line is a planned separation point (OST), a blocking location (PSB), or both. Decide which zones are blocked, how reclosing is supervised and what happens in pilot schemes.

13.4 Step 4 — Set the distance zones

Set zone reaches and resistive reaches for fault coverage and coordination first. Then check them against Attachment B and PRC-023. If a zone fails, consider reshaping before resorting to blocking, because a zone that does not see stable swings needs no blocking at all.

13.5 Step 5 — Set the swing detection
  • Inner characteristic: outside the largest blocked zone with margin (commonly 10 to 20% in impedance).
  • Outer characteristic: inside the PRC-023 load point with margin.
  • Timer ΔT: longer than the fault traverse time for the relay's filter, and short enough that the fastest expected swing still takes longer than ΔT to cross.
  • Reset delay and maximum blocking time from study results.
  • For continuous or swing-center voltage methods, follow the relay's setting rules and verify with simulated swings.
13.6 Step 6 — Set unblocking

Set negative-sequence and zero-sequence ratios above swing and open-pole unbalance, enable three-phase fault detection during swings, and set the unblock timer from the longest credible swing duration.

13.7 Step 7 — Verify

Verify with simulated stable swings, unstable swings and faults during swings, using RMS and, where IBRs are nearby, EMT studies. Play the resulting voltages and currents into the relay or its model.

13.8 Step 8 — Document

Document the philosophy, calculations, plots, test results and compliance evaluations together. The same package supports PRC-026, PRC-023 and PRC-027.

13.9 Summary of setting rules
Setting Rule of thumb Governing constraint
Inner characteristic 10 to 20% outside the largest blocked zone Swing detected before blocked zones pick up
Outer characteristic At least 10 to 20% inside the PRC-023 load point No PSB assertion under heavy load
Spacing Gives travel time above ΔT at the maximum study slip frequency Study-based slip frequency
ΔT Typically 1.5 to 4 cycles; above the relay's minimum for its filter Fault traverse time and filter transient
Unblock (I2/I1, I0) Above swing and open-pole unbalance Unbalance during swings and single-pole trip
Unblock timer Longer than the longest credible swing inside the inner characteristic Stability study
OST trip timing Trip on the way out unless studies require the way in Breaker out-of-phase capability

These are starting points, not substitutes for study results and the relay manufacturer's instructions.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel delivers the full workflow, from line constants and source equivalents through settings, verification and documentation, as a single package for each line. Owners receive settings files, an issued settings report, PRC-026 evaluations and test plans that all reference the same calculations.

14. Testing and commissioning power swing functions

14.1 Why steady-state tests are not enough

Power swing functions respond to the movement of impedance over time. A steady-state test that injects a fixed impedance only checks the boundaries of the characteristics. Proper testing uses dynamic test sequences that move the impedance along a swing locus at a controlled slip frequency, then add faults during the swing.

14.2 Recommended tests
Test Purpose
Characteristic boundary tests Confirm inner and outer characteristics are where they are set
Slow swing (for example, 0.5 Hz) through the characteristics Confirm PSB asserts and blocked zones do not trip
Fast swing at the maximum design slip frequency Confirm detection still operates at the edge of the design range
Swing that stops and returns inside the outer characteristic Confirm the stable swing case and reset behavior
Swing that passes through and exits on the far side Confirm OST operates and trips at the intended point (way in or way out)
Unbalanced fault during a swing Confirm unblocking and fault clearing time
Three-phase fault during a swing near 180 degrees Confirm the three-phase unblocking method
Single-pole open interval during a swing Confirm unblocking does not misoperate on open-pole unbalance
Heavy load at the PRC-023 point Confirm PSB does not assert on load
14.3 Using study results as test inputs

The most convincing tests use voltages and currents taken from the actual system studies, converted to COMTRADE files and played back through a test set. This tests the logic against the trajectories it will actually see, including IBR effects that simple two-source models do not capture.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel prepares dynamic test plans and COMTRADE playback files from our studies, witnesses commissioning tests and reviews results against the settings intent. The test records become part of the PRC-026 R4 implementation evidence where a CAP is involved.

15. How PRC-026 fits with other NERC standards

Standard Relationship to power swing protection
PRC-023 Transmission relay loadability. Sets the steady-state load limit that the outer swing characteristic and distance zones must respect.
PRC-025 Generator relay loadability. Covers generator and GSU relays under steady-state stressed conditions; PRC-026 covers the dynamic swing case for the same relays where identified.
PRC-027 Coordination of protection systems for performance during faults. Any CAP that reshapes zones must keep coordination, and the PRC-027 short-circuit model provides source equivalents.
PRC-004 Misoperation identification and correction. A trip during a stable swing is usually a misoperation; the PRC-004 review should also trigger the PRC-026 R2 event-driven evaluation.
PRC-005 Protection system maintenance. Power swing functions and their test results are part of the maintained Protection System.
PRC-019, PRC-024, PRC-029 Generator voltage regulation and protection coordination, and ride-through requirements. Generator and IBR settings that change swing behavior must remain consistent with these standards.
PRC-030 IBR unexpected performance events. Swing-related IBR tripping or power reductions can be PRC-030 events.
TPL-001 Transmission planning. The annual Planning Assessment is a primary source of PRC-026 R1 Element identification.
MOD-032, MOD-026, MOD-027 Model data and model verification. Accurate generator and IBR models are the basis for credible swing studies.
FAC-011, FAC-014 System Operating Limits methodology. Angular stability SOLs feed R1 Criteria 1 and 2.

How Keentel Engineering helps here. Keentel's NERC compliance practice maintains a single compliance matrix for clients that links each Element, each relay and each standard, so that a settings change made for one standard is checked against the others before it is issued.

16. Common mistakes and how to avoid them

Mistake Consequence Better practice
Enabling PSB with factory default characteristics and timers Fast swings missed, or blocking asserted during heavy load Set characteristics and timers from study results and PRC-023 load points
Blocking every zone on every line System cannot separate when it must; generators trip unpredictably Plan OST at separation points; block elsewhere
No three-phase fault detection during swings A three-phase fault during a swing is cleared only by the unblock timer or backup Enable and test three-phase unblocking methods
Ignoring single-pole open intervals Sequence-based unblocking releases during the open interval Supervise unblocking during open-pole conditions
Using a long-reach zone 3 mho as remote backup without swing review Trips on stable swings and stressed conditions Quadrilateral or lens shaping, PSB supervision, or remote backup by breaker failure and local redundancy
Evaluating PRC-026 with design settings rather than as-left settings Evaluation does not reflect the field Retrieve and evaluate as-left settings
Treating PSB as the default CAP Unblocking risks added without review Prefer reshaping where fault coverage allows; add PSB only with full unblocking design
Ignoring IBR effects Detection or unblocking behaves differently from two-source assumptions EMT studies and playback tests in IBR-heavy areas

17. Practical checklist

  • Confirm whether the Planning Coordinator has notified any of your Elements under R1, and track the 12-month clock from each notification.
  • Confirm your process for recognizing trips caused by stable or unstable swings, and link it to PRC-004 reviews.
  • List every load-responsive element on each identified Element, and log any Attachment A exclusion with its justification.
  • Plot each characteristic against the Attachment B region using current source impedances.
  • For failing elements, prepare CAP options within six months and track them to completion.
  • Check every outer swing characteristic against the PRC-023 load point.
  • Confirm that swing timers and spacing cover the study-based slip frequency range.
  • Test unblocking for unbalanced and three-phase faults during swings, and for open-pole conditions.
  • Confirm out-of-step tripping locations, trip timing and breaker out-of-phase capability.
  • Keep studies, settings, evaluations and test results in one controlled package.

Part C — Three Anonymous US Case Studies

The following case studies are composites based on typical engagements. Names, locations and identifying details have been changed or omitted.

Case Study 1 — Southeastern 500/230 kV utility: zone 2 trips on a stable swing

Situation. A vertically integrated utility in the Southeast experienced an unexpected trip of a 230 kV line during a fault on an adjacent 500 kV corridor. The 500 kV fault was cleared normally in about 4 cycles. About 0.6 seconds later, a 230 kV line roughly 40 miles away tripped on zone 2 time delay from one terminal. No fault was found on the 230 kV line. The utility's PRC-004 review classified the trip as a misoperation, and the compliance team asked whether PRC-026 applied.

Analysis. Keentel retrieved oscillography from both terminals and phasor data from a nearby PMU. The apparent impedance at the tripping terminal moved slowly from the load region into the zone 2 mho characteristic, stayed there for about 25 cycles and then moved out again. The recorded slip at entry was about 0.7 Hz. Reconstruction with the planning model showed a stable inter-area swing that reached about 105 degrees across the equivalent system at the line terminals. The zone 2 mho was set at 140% of the line with an 85-degree maximum torque angle. Using the Attachment B construction with the Planning Coordinator's equivalents, the zone 2 characteristic was entered at swing angles as low as about 98 degrees, so it did not meet Criterion A. The trip was a stable power swing trip, which started the R2 event-driven 12-month clock.

Engineered solution. Keentel evaluated three CAP options: reducing zone 2 reach, converting zone 2 to a quadrilateral, and supervising zone 2 with power swing blocking. A reach reduction would have lost coordination with a long adjacent line. A quadrilateral with resistive blinders at ±18 Ω primary kept fault coverage for the line's calculated arc and tower footing resistance and met Attachment B with the smallest boundary angle above 130 degrees. The utility chose the quadrilateral conversion, and Keentel checked PRC-023 loadability and PRC-027 coordination for the new settings.

Outcome. The CAP was documented within two months of the evaluation and implemented at the next planned outage. During a similar 500 kV fault the following year, the 230 kV line rode through with the swing impedance passing outside the new characteristic. The evaluation, CAP and implementation records were included in the utility's PRC-026 evidence package and passed its subsequent audit without findings.

Case Study 2 — Western 345 kV transmission owner: a separation point that would not separate

Situation. A transmission owner in the West operated a 345 kV path that planning studies identified as a separation point for an unstable swing between two load-generation areas. The out-of-step tripping scheme had been installed years earlier. Following a transmission expansion and the retirement of a nearby coal unit, the Planning Coordinator's R1 notification included the path's lines under Criterion 4, and the owner asked Keentel to review both PRC-026 compliance and the OST scheme.

Analysis. Keentel rebuilt the equivalents using the current planning case. Two changes stood out. First, the electrical center for the critical unstable case had moved by about 15% of the line length toward the receiving end, still on the line but closer to the remote bus. Second, the maximum slip frequency in the new unstable cases had risen from about 2 Hz to about 4 Hz, partly because of reduced synchronous inertia on the sending side, where large solar and battery plants had replaced the retired unit. The existing concentric characteristics were spaced for 2 Hz with a 2-cycle timer. At 4 Hz, the swing crossed in about 1 cycle, so the scheme treated it as a fault: blocking did not assert, and the OST logic did not see a slow traverse. Zone 1 would have tripped on the way in, near 150 degrees, with the breakers opening close to the out-of-phase condition.

Engineered solution. Keentel recommended moving to a swing-center voltage based detection method available in the existing relays, with concentric characteristics retained as a secondary check. Keentel ran RMS studies for the full contingency set and PSCAD studies for the cases near the solar and battery plants to verify that detection operated at slips up to about 5 Hz. OST timing was changed to trip on the way out, which kept breaker voltage below about 1.4 per unit in the studied cases, and the owner confirmed breaker out-of-phase capability with the manufacturer. Zone 2 at the same terminals failed Attachment B and was supervised by PSB, with negative-sequence and three-phase unblocking tested using study-based playback.

Outcome. The revised scheme was commissioned with dynamic tests at 0.5, 2 and 5 Hz and faults during swings. The PRC-026 evaluation, CAP and the OST redesign were documented as a single package. The planning department adopted Keentel's recommendation to re-screen the separation scheme each time the Planning Coordinator's assessment shows a material change in slip frequency or electrical center location.

Case Study 3 — Texas wind and storage plant: generator tie line identified under R1

Situation. A 300 MW wind plant with a 100 MW battery storage addition in Texas was connected through a 25-mile 138 kV generator tie line to a 345/138 kV substation. After the battery addition, the Planning Coordinator's annual assessment showed relay tripping on a stable swing in a simulated disturbance, and the Generator Owner received a PRC-026 R1 notification for the tie line and the main power transformer.

Analysis. Keentel evaluated all load-responsive elements: tie line phase distance zones 1 to 3 at the plant end, a phase overcurrent backup on the main power transformer, and loss-of-field style elements in the plant protection. The tie line zone 3, set as a long-reach mho for remote backup into the 345 kV system, failed Criterion A. The transformer overcurrent backup passed Criterion B by a comfortable margin. Keentel also ran PSCAD simulations with the wind turbine and battery inverter models. During the swing, the plant controller's reactive current response changed the apparent impedance trajectory, making it less regular than a two-source swing, and the battery's negative-sequence injection during an unbalanced fault in the swing was enough to operate the existing unblocking ratio only after about 2 cycles.

Engineered solution. The CAP replaced the long-reach zone 3 mho with a quadrilateral zone 3 with resistive blinders set from fault coverage and Attachment B, and added a direct transfer trip scheme from the 345/138 kV substation for faults in the transformer zone that zone 3 had previously backed up. The negative-sequence unblocking ratio was adjusted using the EMT results, keeping margin over swing unbalance. Keentel coordinated the changes with the plant's PRC-024 and PRC-029 ride-through settings and updated the MOD-032 protection data submitted to the Planning Coordinator.

Outcome. The CAP was completed within the plant's next maintenance window. Keentel prepared the R2 evaluation, CAP and R4 implementation evidence, plus a short narrative for the RSAW, and set up an annual check so that future R1 notifications and planning case changes trigger a re-evaluation without delay.


Part D — Technical FAQ

1. What is a power swing?

A power swing is a variation in active and reactive power flow caused by changes in the relative angles of groups of synchronous machines after a disturbance such as a fault, line switching, generator trip or large load change. The angle between the equivalent internal voltages oscillates, power follows a sine relationship with that angle, and voltage magnitudes along the system vary as well. A swing is stable if the angle reaches a maximum and returns, and unstable if the angle keeps increasing and the systems lose synchronism.

2. Why do distance relays respond to power swings?

Distance relays measure apparent impedance as the ratio of local voltage to local current. During a swing, voltage at the relay falls and current rises as the angle increases, so apparent impedance moves from the load region toward the line impedance. If it enters a relay zone for longer than the zone's time delay, the relay trips, even though no fault exists.

3. What is the electrical center of a swing?

It is the point along the total system impedance where voltage passes through zero when the angle between the equivalent sources reaches 180 degrees. For equal source magnitudes it is the midpoint of the total impedance. Lines containing the electrical center see the swing deepest in their zones and are natural candidates for out-of-step tripping.

4. How is the swing locus calculated?

With source voltage ratio n and angle δ, the apparent impedance at the sending-end relay is Z_T·n·e^(jδ)/(n·e^(jδ) − 1) − Z_S. For equal sources the locus is the perpendicular bisector of the total system impedance; for unequal sources it is a circle bulging toward the weaker-voltage end. Worked Example 1 shows numerical values for a 345 kV line.

5. What is the difference between power swing blocking and out-of-step tripping?

Power swing blocking prevents selected distance elements from tripping while a swing is detected, so lines stay in service during stable swings. Out-of-step tripping deliberately trips breakers when a swing is unstable, separating the system at planned locations. A complete scheme uses both, applied at different locations according to a planning-based philosophy.

6. How does the classic two-characteristic method detect a swing?

It places an outer and an inner characteristic around the distance zones and times how long the impedance takes to cross between them. A traverse slower than a set time ΔT indicates a swing; a near-instantaneous traverse indicates a fault. The swing condition is held while the impedance remains inside the outer characteristic and resets after it leaves.

7. Does leaving the outer characteristic mean a trip is permitted?

Not directly. Leaving the outer characteristic resets swing detection, restoring normal operation of the distance elements after a reset delay. Tripping still requires a fault inside a zone. Faults that occur while the impedance is inside the outer characteristic are handled by unblocking logic, not by leaving the characteristic.

8. How should the inner and outer characteristics be set?

The inner characteristic should enclose the largest zone to be blocked with margin, typically 10 to 20% in impedance. The outer characteristic should stay inside the PRC-023 load point with margin. The spacing should give a traverse time longer than ΔT at the highest slip frequency expected from studies. When these constraints conflict, the zone shapes or the detection method should be changed.

9. What slip frequency should be used for settings?

The maximum slip frequency should come from stability studies of the critical disturbances. Values of 2 to 5 Hz are common for transmission systems, with higher values near small, low-inertia plants. The setting should also cover the slowest swings, so that reset and maximum blocking timers do not release during a slow swing.

10. How is the PSB timer related to slip frequency?

The time to cross between characteristics is the angular spacing divided by 360 degrees times the slip frequency. For 16.6 degrees of spacing, the crossing takes 2.8 cycles at 1 Hz and 0.69 cycle at 4 Hz. The timer must be shorter than the crossing time at the maximum slip but longer than the fault traverse time, including the relay's filter transient.

11. What is swing-center voltage, and why is it useful?

Swing-center voltage is an estimate of the voltage at the electrical center, approximately the local voltage magnitude times the cosine of the angle between local voltage and current. It falls smoothly from about 1 per unit toward zero as the swing angle approaches 180 degrees. Its rate of change distinguishes swings, which change it smoothly, from faults, which change it abruptly, with little dependence on system impedances.

12. What are continuous impedance methods?

They track the apparent impedance trajectory continuously and test its rate of change, smoothness and consistency between phases, rather than timing the crossing between two fixed boundaries. They need fewer system-specific settings and handle faster swings, but their logic varies between relays and they need dynamic testing.

13. How do relays detect unbalanced faults during a swing?

Unbalanced faults produce negative-sequence and, for ground faults, zero-sequence current, which a balanced swing does not. Unblocking logic releases the block when sequence current exceeds a ratio of positive-sequence current or a threshold. Settings must exceed the unbalance from the swing, from untransposed lines and from open poles.

14. How are three-phase faults during a swing detected?

Because a three-phase fault is balanced, relays use other signatures: a sudden jump in impedance or swing-center voltage, a swing-center voltage that stays near zero for longer than a swing would allow, or low voltage with low power factor for a set time. A fallback unblock timer releases the block if the impedance stays inside the inner characteristic too long.

15. Should zone 1 be blocked during swings?

It depends on the philosophy and the location. If zone 1 covers the electrical center of a stable swing, it will see the swing and should be blocked or reshaped. If the line is a planned separation point, zone 1 may be allowed to trip on unstable swings or replaced by dedicated out-of-step tripping. The decision should come from studies and be documented.

16. Should reclosing be blocked during swings?

Generally yes. Reclosing into a large angle can cause severe torque and current transients and can trip the line again. Reclosing should be supervised by synchronism checks and blocked while a swing is detected.

17. Are line current differential relays affected by power swings?

Line current differential protection compares current entering and leaving the line, and a swing is a through condition, so it does not cause a differential trip. Distance backup elements in the same relay can still respond to swings and must be set accordingly. Differential relays are not a complete answer for PRC-026, because backup and remote elements still need evaluation.

18. What does NERC PRC-026 require?

PRC-026 requires Planning Coordinators to identify, annually, generator, transformer and transmission line BES Elements that meet specified criteria related to angular stability and swing tripping. Generator Owners and Transmission Owners must then evaluate the load-responsive protective relays on those Elements against Attachment B within 12 full calendar months, develop a Corrective Action Plan within six full calendar months for any relay that does not meet the criteria, and implement it.

19. Which relays does PRC-026 cover?

Load-responsive protective relays applied at the terminals of the applicable BES Elements, typically phase distance, phase overcurrent, out-of-step tripping and loss-of-field elements. Attachment A lists exclusions, such as elements supervised by power swing blocking and elements enabled only when other systems fail. The current text should be checked for the full list.

20. What is the 120-degree criterion?

Attachment B evaluates relay characteristics against an unstable power swing region built around a system separation angle of 120 degrees and a range of source voltage ratios. Stable swings rarely exceed about 120 degrees, so a characteristic that can only be entered beyond that angle is not expected to trip on stable swings. A characteristic entered at smaller angles fails the criterion.

21. How is Criterion B for overcurrent relays applied?

The pickup of an overcurrent element used for tripping must be above the current flowing during a stable swing at a 120-degree separation angle with the source voltages and system conditions specified in the standard. For the 345 kV example, the swing current is about 3,500 A primary, so a phase overcurrent pickup must exceed that value to pass.

22. What triggers an event-driven PRC-026 evaluation?

When a Generator Owner or Transmission Owner becomes aware that an applicable generator, transformer or transmission line Element tripped in response to a stable or unstable power swing due to its protective relays, it must evaluate the load-responsive relays on that Element against Attachment B within 12 full calendar months. Linking PRC-004 misoperation reviews to PRC-026 ensures these events are recognized.

23. What should a PRC-026 Corrective Action Plan contain?

It should identify the relay and element that failed, the root cause, the actions chosen (for example, reshaping, reach change or adding power swing blocking), the responsible parties, a timetable, and how fault detection and out-of-step tripping remain dependable. It must be developed within six full calendar months of the failed evaluation and updated if actions or timetables change.

24. Is adding power swing blocking always the best CAP?

No. PSB brings its own risks, particularly for faults during swings. Where fault coverage allows, reshaping a zone so it does not see stable swings is often simpler and more robust. Where PSB is added, unblocking logic must be designed and tested, and the effect on any out-of-step tripping at that terminal must be reviewed.

25. How does PRC-023 interact with power swing settings?

PRC-023 sets the steady-state loadability requirement, commonly 150% of the highest seasonal 4-hour Facility Rating at 0.85 per-unit voltage and a 30-degree angle. The outer power swing characteristic must stay clear of that load point, or PSB will assert during heavy load. The same load point often limits how wide the characteristics can be spaced for fast swings.

26. How do inverter-based resources affect power swing protection?

They reduce inertia, supply limited and controlled fault current, inject negative-sequence current according to their controls and IEEE 2800 requirements, and can create control-driven oscillations. Swing trajectories near IBR plants can be faster and less regular than two-source models predict. EMT studies and playback testing are recommended for detection and unblocking near large IBR plants.

27. What is trip on the way in versus trip on the way out?

Trip on the way in initiates out-of-step tripping as soon as the swing is judged unstable, typically on entering the inner characteristic. Trip on the way out waits until the impedance has passed through the line axis and is leaving. Way-out tripping usually opens breakers at smaller voltages across the contacts; way-in tripping shortens the disturbance but may require out-of-phase rated breakers.

28. How should power swing functions be tested?

With dynamic test sequences that move the impedance along swing loci at controlled slip frequencies, including slow and fast swings, swings that return, swings that pass through, unbalanced and three-phase faults during swings, open-pole intervals and heavy load. Playback of voltages and currents from system studies in COMTRADE format gives the most realistic tests.

29. How often should PRC-026 evaluations be repeated?

The standard requires evaluation after an R1 notification where an Attachment B evaluation has not been performed in the last five calendar years, and after a swing-related trip. Good practice is also to re-screen when settings change, when the Planning Coordinator's equivalents change materially, or when new generation, especially IBRs, alters swing behavior.

30. What evidence do auditors typically expect for PRC-026?

Dated R1 notifications, a list of applicable Elements and load-responsive relays, Attachment A exclusion justifications, Attachment B evaluations with plots and calculations, CAPs with dates and approvals, implementation records and as-left settings, and a procedure showing how swing-related trips are identified. Keentel prepares this evidence in an indexed, RSAW-ready format.


How Keentel Engineering Helps


Keentel Engineering is a US power systems engineering firm that delivers protection, studies and NERC compliance services from 4 kV to 765 kV. For power swing protection and PRC-026, our services include:


  • PRC-026 compliance programs. R1 Element identification support for Planning Coordinators, R2 relay evaluations against Attachment B, R3 Corrective Action Plans, R4 implementation support, five-year re-evaluation tracking and RSAW-ready evidence.
  • Protection settings development and peer review. Distance, power swing blocking, out-of-step tripping, pilot schemes, line differential, breaker failure and reclosing settings for 69 kV to 765 kV lines, and generator and IBR plant protection.
  • Stability and swing studies. PSS/E, PSLF and PSCAD studies of stable and unstable swings, slip frequencies, electrical center locations and critical clearing times, including TPL-001 dynamic assessments.
  • Short-circuit modeling and line constants. Source equivalents, line impedance calculations and coordination studies that feed PRC-026, PRC-023 and PRC-027 consistently.
  • NERC relay loadability and coordination. PRC-023, PRC-025 and PRC-027 evaluations, and integration with PRC-019, PRC-024, PRC-029 and PRC-030 for generator and IBR owners.
  • Event analysis and misoperation review. Oscillography, PMU and sequence-of-events analysis to determine whether trips were caused by faults or swings, with PRC-004 and PRC-026 follow-up.
  • Testing and commissioning. Dynamic test plans, COMTRADE playback from studies, test witnessing and PRC-005 maintenance support.
  • Owner's engineer services. Technical oversight of utility, generator and developer projects where protection and NERC compliance are critical.


Why Clients Choose Keentel


  • Protection and planning under one roof. The same team runs the stability studies and sets the relays, so settings and compliance evaluations use one consistent model.
  • Compliance-ready deliverables. Every evaluation is dated, traceable and organized for audit, with clear links to the requirement it satisfies.
  • Licensed professional engineers. Work is prepared and reviewed by licensed professional engineers with transmission, generation and IBR experience.
  • Practical solutions. We prefer the simplest robust fix, such as reshaping a zone before adding blocking logic, and we explain trade-offs in writing.
  • IBR expertise. We model wind, solar and storage plants in EMT detail and understand how they change swing and fault behavior.
  • Responsive and independent. We work for owners, not relay vendors, and our recommendations are based on engineering, not product.


Talk to Keentel Engineering


Whether you have just received a PRC-026 R1 notification, need a review of your power swing blocking and out-of-step philosophy, or are investigating a trip that looked like a swing, Keentel Engineering can help.


  • Phone: (813) 389-7871
  • Email: contact@keentelengineering.com
  • Book a 15-minute consultation: calendly.com/keentel-engineering/15min


References


  • NERC Reliability Standard PRC-026-1, Relay Performance During Stable Power Swings, including Attachments A and B. North American Electric Reliability Corporation.
  • FERC Order No. 818, Reliability Standard for Transmission System Relay Performance During Stable Power Swings (approving PRC-026-1).
  • NERC System Protection and Control Subcommittee, Protection System Response to Power Swings, technical reference document, August 2013.
  • NERC Reliability Standards PRC-004, PRC-005, PRC-023, PRC-024, PRC-025, PRC-027, PRC-029, PRC-030, TPL-001, MOD-026, MOD-027 and MOD-032.
  • IEEE Std C37.113, Guide for Protective Relay Applications to Transmission Lines.
  • IEEE Std C37.104, Guide for Automatic Reclosing on AC Distribution and Transmission Lines.
  • IEEE Std C37.102, Guide for AC Generator Protection.
  • IEEE Std 2800-2022, Standard for Interconnection and Interoperability of Inverter-Based Resources Interconnecting with Associated Transmission Electric Power Systems.
  • IEEE Std C37.06 and C37.04, AC high-voltage circuit breaker ratings and requirements, including out-of-phase switching.
  • U.S.–Canada Power System Outage Task Force, Final Report on the August 14, 2003 Blackout in the United States and Canada, April 2004.
  • P. Kundur, Power System Stability and Control. McGraw-Hill.
  • J. L. Blackburn and T. J. Domin, Protective Relaying: Principles and Applications. CRC Press.
  • S. H. Horowitz and A. G. Phadke, Power System Relaying. Wiley.
  • G. Ziegler, Numerical Distance Protection: Principles and Applications.


Disclaimer


This article provides general technical information for educational purposes. Numerical examples use illustrative system data and simplified models, and summaries of NERC Reliability Standards are paraphrased; the official text of each standard governs. Settings for any specific facility must be based on system-specific studies, the relay manufacturer's instructions and the applicable standards in effect. This article does not constitute engineering advice for any particular project and does not create a professional relationship. Contact Keentel Engineering for project-specific support.


© 2026 Keentel Engineering. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reproduced or distributed without the written permission of Keentel Engineering.



A smiling man with glasses and a beard wearing a blue blazer stands in front of server racks in a data center.

About the Author:

Sandip "Sonny" R. Patel, P.E.

IEEE Senior Member · Founder & CEO, Keentel Engineering

In 1995, Sonny Patel earned his Electrical Engineering degree from the University of Illinois. But degrees don't build legacies — action does.

For three decades, he has worked the power industry from every side of the table: 16 years as a utility engineer at Exelon/Commonwealth Edison; generation leadership across hydroelectric, industrial steam turbine, and a 9 GW renewable fleet; NERC Regional Entity Senior Compliance Engineer and Audit Team Lead, auditing some of the nation's largest utilities; and testing and commissioning lead on equipment up to 765 kV — the very top of the North American grid.Utility. Generator. Regulator. Consultant. Few engineers have seen all four seats. Fewer still have sat in them.

His experience spans nuclear, hydro, conventional generation, renewables, oil and gas, mining — and today's data centers, where he is authoring a three-book series on data center design. He is a Licensed Professional Engineer in six states and a Licensed Electrical Contractor in Florida (Unlimited EC) — he doesn't just design the work; he's qualified to stand behind its execution.Today, as Founder and CEO of Keentel Engineering, Sonny leads a nationwide team of engineers delivering substation design, power system studies, NERC compliance, and commissioning — done right, coast to coast.Three decades. Every side of the table. One standard: accountable engineering.

Four workers in safety vests and helmets stand with arms crossed near wind turbines.

Let's Discuss Your Project

Let's book a call to discuss your electrical engineering project that we can help you with.

Man in a blazer and open shirt, looking at the camera, against a blurred background.

About the Author:

Sandip "Sonny" R. Patel, P.E.

IEEE Senior Member · Founder & CEO, Keentel Engineering

In 1995, Sonny Patel earned his Electrical Engineering degree from the University of Illinois. But degrees don't build legacies — action does.

For three decades, he has worked the power industry from every side of the table: 16 years as a utility engineer at Exelon/Commonwealth Edison; generation leadership across hydroelectric, industrial steam turbine, and a 9 GW renewable fleet; NERC Regional Entity Senior Compliance Engineer and Audit Team Lead, auditing some of the nation's largest utilities; and testing and commissioning lead on equipment up to 765 kV — the very top of the North American grid.

Utility. Generator. Regulator. Consultant. Few engineers have seen all four seats. Fewer still have sat in them.

His experience spans nuclear, hydro, conventional generation, renewables, oil and gas, mining — and today's data centers, where he is authoring a three-book series on data center design. He is a Licensed Professional Engineer in six states and a Licensed Electrical Contractor in Florida (Unlimited EC) — he doesn't just design the work; he's qualified to stand behind its execution.

Today, as Founder and CEO of Keentel Engineering, Sonny leads a nationwide team of engineers delivering substation design, power system studies, NERC compliance, and commissioning — done right, coast to coast.Three decades. Every side of the table. One standard: accountable engineering.

Leave a Comment

Related Posts

NEC 2026 Field Guide showing electrical code changes for load calculations, grounding, energy manage
By SANDIP R PATEL • November 14, 2026
Explore NEC 2026 changes to load calculations, grounding, ampacity, wiring, solar, ESS and EV systems with Keentel Engineering's practical field guide. Copy
Data Center Tiers I–IV comparison showing redundancy, concurrent maintainability and fault tolerance
By SANDIP R PATEL • November 14, 2026
Explore Data Center Tiers I–IV, N+1 vs. 2N redundancy, concurrent maintainability, fault tolerance, and MEP design requirements with Keentel Engineering.
NERC compliance engineering standards covering PRC, MOD, TPL, FAC, VAR, EOP and CIP.
By SANDIP R PATEL • November 14, 2026
Explore NERC compliance engineering for generator and transmission owners, IBRs and large loads, covering PRC, MOD, TPL standards, audits and modeling.
LVRT to HVRT transition in weak grids showing post-fault overvoltage and inverter voltage response.
By SANDIP R PATEL • November 14, 2026
Learn why LVRT becomes HVRT in weak grids, how post-fault overvoltage trips solar, wind and BESS plants, and how Keentel Engineering uses EMT studies.
STATCOM V-I characteristic graph showing voltage regulation, current limits and short-term overload.
By SANDIP R PATEL • November 14, 2026
Explore STATCOM V-I characteristics, voltage control slope, current limits, short-term overload ratings, reactive power and low-voltage grid performance.
Ground distance protection R-X diagram showing mho and quadrilateral relay settings for a 230 kV lin
By SANDIP R PATEL • November 12, 2026
Learn ground distance protection settings for transmission lines: k0 compensation, mho and quadrilateral relays, mutual coupling and NERC compliance.
800 VDC vs. 1,500 VDC AI data center power distribution chart comparing rack current and conductor l
By SANDIP R PATEL • November 12, 2026
Compare 800 VDC vs. 1500 VDC for AI data centers. Explore efficiency, copper savings, DC protection, safety and power distribution with Keentel Engineering.
Transformer overcurrent protection 51/50 time-current coordination curves showing relay settings and
By SANDIP R PATEL • November 12, 2026
Learn transformer overcurrent protection using 50/51 relay stages, inverse-time curves, inrush checks, fault coordination and arc-flash mitigation.
SVC vs. STATCOM reactive power comparison showing voltage stability and performance during voltage s
By SANDIP R PATEL • November 12, 2026
Compare SVC vs. STATCOM for dynamic reactive power compensation, voltage stability, weak grids, response time, harmonics and transmission system design.