A Coordinated Electric System Interconnection Review—the utility’s deep-dive on technical and cost impacts of your project.

Optimizing MV Switchgear Design for Cost, Safety & Compliance

Date icon D

May 8, 2025 | Blog

Optimizing MV Switchgear Design for Cost, Safety & Compliance

In today’s competitive power engineering landscape, MV switchgear design must balance performance, cost-effectiveness, and adherence to standards such as IEC 62271-307 and IEC 60943. At Keentel Engineering, we leverage advanced thermal and electromagnetic simulations alongside decades of hands-on expertise to deliver optimized panel, switchboard, and busway solutions—whether for rural electrification, offshore platforms, or high-density urban substations.


Key Insights & Economic Strategies

A recent comparative study by Keentel Engineering demonstrates how early-stage simulations can:

  • Replace costly lab tests (temperature-rise or internal-arc tests costing up to €30 000) with validated digital models
  • Optimize material selection (Copper vs. Aluminum vs. CCA) to achieve the best cost-per-MVA and thermal performance
  • Enable compact GIS-based designs by fine-tuning ventilation, busbar geometry, and hybrid conductor profiles

We adhere to IEC 62271-307 for temperature limits and IEC 60943 for busbar mechanical criteria, ensuring both safety and UL/CE compliance.


FAQs

  • What’s the cost of an MV switchgear temperature-rise test?

    Roughly €4 000 plus 1.5 days of lab time.

  • Why use simulation in switchgear development?

    Simulations cut lab costs and accelerate design iterations by up to 40%.

  • Which busbar materials were compared?

    Copper, Aluminum, and CCA (Copper-Clad Aluminum).

  • How do ventilation openings impact thermal performance?

    A 10 % increase in vent area can reduce temperature rise by 15 %.

  • What current rating benchmark was validated?

    Baseline: 1 250 A @ 75 K; Target: 1 600–1 750 A with optimized designs.

  • Which IEC standard governs switchgear temperature rises?

    IEC 62271-307 sets limits (75 K max at busbar/CB junctions).

  • Which design had the lowest cost per MVA?

    Design 4 (Aluminum U-profile): ~$14 USD/MVA.

  • What factors limit MV switchgear performance?

    Testing costs, junction temperature rises, and outdated materials.

  • How does Keentel apply these findings?

    Through simulation-driven design reviews and targeted busbar optimizations.

  • Can these strategies apply to Substation Design?

    Absolutely—see our Substation Design Services for end-to-end primary and secondary engineering.


Case Studies

Case Study 1: 1 600 A Switchgear Panel Redesign

  • Client: Confidential MV Manufacturer
  • Challenge: Upgrade 1 250 A panel to 1 600 A without exceeding 75 K rise
  • Solution: Thermal simulations of five busbar layouts
  • Result: Ventilated copper busbars achieved 1 695 A @ 75 K and cut cost/MVA by 36 %

Case Study 2: Rural Substation Cost Reduction

  • Client: Utility in Latin America
  • Challenge: Lower busbar costs while maintaining performance
  • Solution: CCA busbars with copper cladding
  • Result: Thermal compliance at 1 700 A and 45 % cost savings vs. pure copper

Case Study 3: Compact Offshore Panel

  • Client: Offshore Platform Developer
  • Challenge: High-density footprint with harsh-environment demands
  • Solution: Hybrid copper-aluminum profiles + optimized ventilation
  • Result: 1 750 A panel @ $22/MVA, fully GIS-compatible

Why Keentel Engineering?

  • Deep MV Expertise: Decades in EHV, HV & MV Power System Studies
  • Simulation-Backed: From thermal to internal-arc analyses
  • Standards-Driven: Full compliance with IEC 62271, UL, and CE
  • Cost Optimization: Material trade-off assessments reducing your CAPEX
  • Client-Centric: Tailored reviews aligned to your budget and timeline

Learn more about our full EHV, HV, MV Power System Studies or contact us for a design consultation.


Ready to Transform Your Switchgear Design?

Don’t let outdated materials or excessive testing costs hold you back—partner with Keentel Engineering for simulation-driven, IEC-compliant switchgear solutions tailored to your project needs.



A bald man with a beard is wearing a suit and a white shirt.

About the Author:

Sonny Patel P.E. EC

IEEE Senior Member

In 1995, Sandip (Sonny) R. Patel earned his Electrical Engineering degree from the University of Illinois, specializing in Electrical Engineering . But degrees don’t build legacies—action does. For three decades, he’s been shaping the future of engineering, not just as a licensed Professional Engineer across multiple states (Florida, California, New York, West Virginia, and Minnesota), but as a doer. A builder. A leader. Not just an engineer. A Licensed Electrical Contractor in Florida with an Unlimited EC license. Not just an executive. The founder and CEO of KEENTEL LLC—where expertise meets execution. Three decades. Multiple states. Endless impact.

A group of construction workers are standing next to each other with their arms crossed.

Let's Discuss Your Project

Let's book a call to discuss your electrical engineering project that we can help you with.

A bald man with a beard is wearing a suit and a white shirt.

About the Author:

Sonny Patel P.E. EC

IEEE Senior Member

In 1995, Sandip (Sonny) R. Patel earned his Electrical Engineering degree from the University of Illinois, specializing in Electrical Engineering . But degrees don’t build legacies—action does. For three decades, he’s been shaping the future of engineering, not just as a licensed Professional Engineer across multiple states (Florida, California, New York, West Virginia, and Minnesota), but as a doer. A builder. A leader. Not just an engineer. A Licensed Electrical Contractor in Florida with an Unlimited EC license. Not just an executive. The founder and CEO of KEENTEL LLC—where expertise meets execution. Three decades. Multiple states. Endless impact.

Leave a Comment

Related Posts

A man in an orange vest is typing on a laptop computer.
By SANDIP R PATEL May 30, 2025
Explore the latest updates from NERC.com and what modernization means for power engineers and grid operators across the U.S.
A row of power lines are silhouetted against a blue sky at sunset.
By SANDIP R PATEL May 30, 2025
Dive deep into power system stability analysis with PSSE, TSAT, and PSCAD/EMTDC—from positive sequence to EMT simulations.
A man wearing a hard hat and safety glasses is using a tablet computer.
By SANDIP R PATEL May 30, 2025
Learn how power system operators can manage data for inverter-based resources (IBRs) using advanced information management practices.
A man is sitting at a desk in front of a computer monitor.
By SANDIP R PATEL May 30, 2025
Understand model accuracy and validation methods in EMT and PSPD simulations for inverter-based resources using top simulation tools.
A man and a woman are looking at a map.
By SANDIP R PATEL May 30, 2025
Explore best practices to ensure design stability in power systems and stay ahead of NERC reporting requirements in upcoming compliance cycles.
Change Management Process in Power Systems
By SANDIP R PATEL May 30, 2025
Discover how structured change management enhances planning and operations in modern power systems for greater reliability and compliance.
PJM Manual 14G Interconnection Services By Keental Engineering
By SANDIP R PATEL May 28, 2025
Navigate PJM generation interconnection with Keentel Engineering. We specialize in queue management, POI support, CIRs, feasibility studies, and SCADA compliance.
NERC Level 3 Alert IBR Generator Owners Compliance Checklist Power System Modeling Model Accuracy
By SANDIP R PATEL May 23, 2025
Get your compliance checklist for NERC Level 3 alerts. Essential reading for IBR generator owners navigating updated NERC requirements.
Integrative Applications of IEEE C57 Series Standards for Reliable and Compliant Substation Design
By SANDIP R PATEL May 21, 2025
Explore how IEEE C57 series standards support transformer reliability, substation diagnostics, and utility compliance in modern substation design.